Introduction
Grasslands are the largest terrestrial ecosystems and provide essential ecological and economic benefits, including biodiversity conservation, climate regulation, and livestock production. However, widespread degradation caused by climate change and human activities threatens grassland ecosystem functions worldwide.
In this paper of Global Meta-analysis Reveals Grassland Restoration Pathways,Chunjun Shi and Ping Li provide a global synthesis of how different restoration measures influence grassland ecosystem services and identifies key environmental factors regulating restoration outcomes.
Highlights
-
This study compares the effectiveness of different grassland restoration measures.
-
Combination measures lead to the highest improvements in services.
-
Fertilization shows limited benefits compared to other methods.
-
Natural recovery and reseeding provide stable benefits in ecosystem services.
-
Restoration outcomes are highly context-dependent on environmental factors.
Core content
Using 96 restoration cases, this study quantified the impacts of four major restoration approaches on grassland ecosystem services.
lCombined measures achieved the greatest improvements
Combination approaches generated the largest enhancement of ecosystem services:Total ecosystem services increased by 94.2%;provisioning services increased by 120.1%;regulating services increased by 102.4%.
lNatural recovery and reseeding provided stable benefits
Natural recovery effectively enhanced ecosystem services:total services increased by 50.7%;provisioning services increased by 96.6%;Regulating services increased by 64.6%.
Reseeding showed even greater improvements:total services increased by 77.7%;provisioning services increased by 152.4%;regulating services increased by 101.1%.
lFertilization showed limited and context-dependent effects
Compared with other approaches, fertilization produced relatively smaller improvements:total ecosystem services increased by 35.5%;provisioning services increased by 57.4%.
lEcosystem services recover at different rates
The recovery of ecosystem services was not synchronized:Provisioning services responded most rapidly to restoration interventions;regulating services showed positive but more environmentally dependent responses;supporting services were more difficult to restore, with only natural recovery showing significant positive effects.
lEnvironmental conditions determine restoration effectiveness
Restoration outcomes varied across environmental gradients:natural recovery performed best under moderate precipitation, suitable elevation, and intermediate ecosystem conditions.Reseeding was most effective in ecosystems with moderate baseline service levels.Combined measures showed stronger advantages in regions with higher precipitation.Fertilization performed poorly at high elevations but showed greater benefits in ecosystems with higher initial quality.
Outlook
Grassland restoration is a complex nonlinear process influenced by restoration approaches, environmental conditions, and ecosystem history. Effective restoration requires moving beyond a one-size-fits-all strategy toward context-dependent and targeted management.Future studies should explore the mechanisms underlying restoration processes, long-term ecosystem responses, and potential synergies among different restoration measures. This study provides global evidence supporting more precise restoration planning and sustainable management of grassland ecosystems.
About the Author
First author:Chunjun Shi is an Assistant Researcher at the Institute of Grassland Research, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, and an Assistant Researcher at Inner Mongolia University of Finance and Economics. She serves as an Executive Committee Member of the Professional Committee of Grassland Economics and Policy of the Chinese Grassland Society. Her research focuses on grassland pastoral economics and policies, pastoral livelihoods, and grassland ecological systems.
Corresponding author: Ping Li is a Researcher at the Institute of Grassland Research, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences. She serves as Deputy Secretary-General of the Chinese Grassland Society, Secretary-General of the Grassland and Animal Husbandry Standardization Working Group of the National Animal Husbandry Standardization Technical Committee, Chair of the China Regional Committee of the International Society for Environment and Rural Sustainable Development, and Secretary-General of the Professional Committee of Grassland Economics and Policy of the Chinese Grassland Society. Her research focuses on grassland conservation policies, pastoral economic institutions, and herder decision-making.