Research based on the interviews of a nearly hundred European officials highlights a fundamental dilemma that characterises Europe’s international relations. Smaller states must work together to survive in an era of competition between superpowers, but the collaboration structures lack flexibility.
European external action is characterised by a fundamental dilemma: joint action is necessary, yet difficult to achieve. This is highlighted in the doctoral dissertation research of Doctoral Researcher Tyyne Karjalainen from the University of Turku in Finland. Her study focused on European joint agency in the context of Russia’s war in Ukraine.
The need for European joint action became even more apparent after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. No European state could alone isolate Russia or sustain Ukraine’s defence effort. Furthermore, protecting the neighbouring states in the “grey zone” with the European Union’s enlargement policy required unanimous action from the 27 EU member states.
However, the collaboration has not been without its challenges. Decoupling from Russia remains partial, military support to Ukraine has often been slow, and the accession processes of new candidate countries have been delayed.
“The conflict in the European international relations shows especially well in the EU’s enlargement policy. Although the policy has been reinstated, enlargement may not be possible,” Karjalainen says.
Joint action could succeed despite the challenges
The study also found explanations for Europe’s limited support to Ukraine. Before Russia launched its full-scale invasion, Europe did not support Ukraine militarily, and even after 2022, the military aid has been characterised by restraint.
“Reasons behind these restraints include European states’ prioritised partnerships with Russia, their interpretations of the expectations and rules of international society, active security roles in other neighbourhoods, particularly in the south, as well as conflicting conceptions of Ukraine,” Karjalainen sums up.
Despite everything, joint action is not doomed to failure. The doctoral dissertation also identifies opportunities for the development of European strategic agency.
“One of the most important conclusions of my research is that the European states do not have to have same objectives in their foreign relations and not all have to participate to the same extent for joint action to succeed. Developing joint external action is possible provided that the states’ objectives overlap sufficiently and the collaboration structures are flexible enough,” Karjalainen says.
In addition, Karjalainen presents different scenarios where the European Union could succeed in enlarging, even amidst geopolitical rivalry.
Research data covers almost one hundred interviews with European officials
Karjalainen's dissertation is based on extensive interview data. She conducted 90 research interviews with officials from ministries of foreign affairs and defence, as well as from embassies and EU institutions located in Belgium, France, Germany, Poland, Romania, Finland, Denmark, Ukraine and Moldova.
Karjalainen based her research on the Interactionist Role Theory, whose well-known creator Professor Sebastian Harnisch from the Heidelberg University in Germany is also Karjalainen’s opponent in the dissertation defence.
“Although my dissertation explores this theory, it also engages in current debates on the shifts in European security policies and, for example, the issues surrounding the provision of military support to Ukraine.”
The research was funded by the Finnish Cultural Foundation. In addition, Turku University Foundation supported the completion of the dissertation by funding Karjalainen's research trip to the Russian and Eurasian Studies Centre of St Antony’s College at the University of Oxford. During her dissertation research, Karjalainen has also worked as a researcher at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs.
Regions: Europe, United Kingdom, Finland, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Moldova, Poland, Romania, Russian Federation, Ukraine
Keywords: Society, Politics